Model comparison

The Scoop 49987 vs FlexBrew 49935 vs 49957

These three Hamilton Beach models share a countertop coffee category but solve different serving patterns. The Scoop 49987 is a grounds-only single-cup brewer. The FlexBrew Advanced 49935 adds pod brewing, hot-over-ice cups and a separate carafe. The FlexBrew Trio 49957 also combines a cup route and a pot, but with a different set of controls. Start with the way coffee is prepared and served—not the number in a product name.

Choose The Scoop 49987 for the grounds cup

The 49987’s reusable mesh Scoop doubles as a measure and brew basket, so its normal routine does not need a paper filter or a single-use pod. Its removable reservoir holds 40 ounces and its two cycle buttons are 8 and 14 ounces. Bold and Regular are available. This is the simplest pick here if you brew your own grounds one mug at a time, and do not want a carafe or pod system. It does not document a 10- or 12-ounce menu, a 16-ounce grounds brew, cold brew, an iced setting or a pot.

Choose FlexBrew Advanced 49935 for the wider menu

The 49935 is the most versatile of the three for households with different cups and inputs. It combines hot single-serve pods or grounds, brewed-over-ice pods or grounds, and a separate 12-cup glass carafe. Its single 60-ounce removable tank can be positioned at the side or back. That broader menu comes with more setup choices and a larger footprint than the 49987; it is not just a grounds-only basket with extra size buttons. For iced coffee, the maker specifies ice quantities for its selected sizes, which is a brewed-over-ice routine rather than a cold-water grounds steep.

Choose FlexBrew Trio 49957 for a hot cup plus a pot

The 49957 pairs a hot single cup—either pods or the included grounds basket—with a 12-cup glass carafe. Its guide documents separate reservoirs, a programmable carafe cycle, Bold/Regular, and a two-hour carafe-side shutoff. The pod route tops out at 10 ounces and the grounds-cup route at 14 ounces. This is a better match than the 49987 when someone needs a morning pod option or a scheduled pot, but it does not document an Over Ice program. The maker’s instructions say it brews one side at a time; having a cup side and a carafe side does not promise concurrent output.

A useful decision sequence

1. If you require both pods and grounds, eliminate the 49987.
2. If you require a carafe, compare the 49935 and 49957 instead of treating the 49987 reservoir as batch capacity. Reservoir ounces are water supply, not brewed coffee held for pouring.
3. If iced coffee is essential, the 49935 documents a brewed-over-ice route; the 49987 and 49957 do not establish one.
4. If all you need is one grounds cup, the Scoop’s reusable basket and two-size workflow avoid paying counter space to support a second brew path.
5. For any hybrid, do not assume that multiple listed modes run at the same time. Select the exact function and check the corresponding operating instructions.

None of these comparisons depends on an unmeasured taste or speed result. It is a question of which documented workflow earns its place on your counter. Read the 49987 assessment, the 49935 assessment, and the 49957 assessment before choosing.

49987 product page · 49935 product page · 49957 product page